🔗 Share this article

This decadently smooth plant-based delight, referred to as a counterpart of butter chicken, is considered one of the widely adored recipes in South Asian cooking. Chef Vivek Singh refers to it as “the best-known and most adapted dish in India,” while fellow chefs note its widespread fame in dining spots across the country.

For those who are new to the universally liked charms of homemade curd cheese in a mild tomato sauce, this recipe presents a great opportunity to sample it. Paneer makhni (butter being the local name for butter) seems remarkably elegant, but it’s fairly easy and quick to make. Serve with naan and a vegetable side to make a full feast.

The Paneer

In the view of cooking enthusiasts, this mild, fresh curd cheese takes a equivalent place as pressed tofu, serving as a texturally satisfying source of protein with a mildly rich taste that flatters, rather than competes with, whatever sauce it’s served in. It's possible to prepare homemade Indian cottage cheese using milk and citric acid, or buy it commonly sold at Indian grocery stores and larger supermarkets.

Some recipes recommend flavoring the cubes before cooking, often with a spice blend that gives an appetising red colour. But, firm commercial paneer can be too dense to absorb much flavour, so seasoning could be more effective with a freshly made cheese.

Alternate approaches suggest browning the cheese before mixing with the gravy. An admired method tosses the chunks in a combination of crushed garlic, ginger, spice, acid, seasoning, yellow spice, and yoghurt, reminiscent of the process used for chicken makhni. The cheese is then baked or crisped to create a crispy exterior.

Alternatively, several experts opt to introduce the paneer at the very end of preparation. This technique maintains the difference between the soft, neutral texture of the cheese and the rich, spiced sauce. For those who prefer a more pronounced flavour in the protein, marinating is a great idea.

Making the Base

The foundation of butter paneer typically commences with onion, grated ginger, and crushed garlic. Some recipes feature caramelised onion to deepen the sweetness, while others use ginger and garlic alone. The creamy elements in paneer makhni contribute a noticeable sugar that works beautifully with softened onion and ginger paste.

In terms of seasonings, the dish generally includes a short list of traditional masalas: haldi, chilli powder, green cardamom, and aromatic mix are popular picks. Certain methods incorporate toasted cumin, fresh coriander, mace, or a bay leaf. The zestiness of green cardamom pairs beautifully with the decadence of cream, while the aromatic elements in garam masala enhance the dish’s taste.

Dried fenugreek leaves, often stirred in at the last stage, are seen as a must for their distinctive bitter, slightly woody taste that brings complexity to the gravy. This element can make a noticeable change in the final dish, reminiscent of its use in other creamy Indian curries.

Regarding the tomato base, a even, lush feel is ideal. For those who choose chopped tomatoes, you may wish to process them with a food processor or strain them to create a uniform sauce. Otherwise, using finely chopped tomatoes can avoid extra steps.

Without access to ripe, tasty ripe tomatoes, it’s best to avoid them, as inferior fruit can create a watery, tart gravy. Many recipes additionally use a spoonful of tomato puree to enhance the savory note. Sweetness can be included to offset the sharpness, with alternatives like granulated sugar or honey depending on preference.

The Dairy

True to its title, creamy butter is a central ingredient in this dish, but several versions also incorporate other creamy ingredients to enhance the luxurious texture. A few experts include Greek yoghurt, double cream, {single cream|light cream|pour